Death at Bibb Graves: Accident or Suicide?

 

The Crime:

On the morning of November 19th, 1962, the Florence Police Department received a call from what was then Florence State College. At approximately 6:30 a.m., a custodian had found the door to the treasurer's office jimmied open, along with other signs of a forced entry. Further inspection inside the office found both an outer vault and an inner safe displaying the same signs of tampering. Missing from the inner safe was $6,000.00 that included the gate from the football game held two days prior at Thomas Braly Jr. Stadium, plus various academic and club fees that had been paid in cash. In terms of today, the take from the theft would equal well over $59,000.00.

When notified, Treasurer Robert C. Fuller rushed to his ground floor office where he met with authorities and commented on the damage. The college treasurer stated he had been in his office on the previous day and had found nothing amiss. A security guard reported he had last checked the three-story building at 3:30 a.m., presumably leaving a three hour window for the crime to have taken place.

The previous March, there had been at least seven burglaries of safes in Lauderdale County that detectives called "rip jobs," but no arrests had been made. All doors to Bibb Graves Hall remained locked when the custodian entered, as did the windows. Investigators remained baffled as to how the theft had occurred, and wild rumors flooded the campus.

Treasurer Robert C. Fuller:

Robert Fuller, known as "Bob" to his friends, was originally from the Alexander City area and started his career as a teacher and principal in the towns of New Hope and Gadsden, coming to work in administration at Florence State in 1944. He had received both a bachelor's and a master's degree in English literature from Auburn, having done his master's thesis on Thomas S. Stribling. During his research of Pulitzer Prize winning author Stribling, Fuller forged a life-long friendship with the Gravelly Springs native. It had been said that if you wanted Stribling to speak at any local event, the best way to secure his presence was first to contact Bob Fuller. 

Fuller's wife, Eva Ellen Aldridge Slaton Fuller, was six years her husband's junior and a science teacher at Appleby Junior High School. Both were active members of the First Christian Church whose building adjoined the college campus. In short, Robert C. Fuller was what anyone would have called a pillar of the community. It was obviously distressing to the college administrator to hear remarks that some malfeasance on his part had led to the theft.

The Bibb Graves Tower:

The Bibb Graves administration building had been built in 1930. It consisted of basement classrooms, administrative offices on the ground floor, two additional floors of classrooms, and a tower that housed a set of Deagan tubular chimes connected to clockwork. 

By 1964, the chimes were 34 years old and required the touch of someone familiar with their components to keep them in working order. That person was Bob Fuller who was often seen ascending the Bibb Graves staircases to the small tower. 

The Fall:

On February 17, 1964, Leatrice Timmons was teaching a freshman Engish composition class in the basement of Bibb Graves Hall. Students who sat by the classroom windows outlined by a brick well usually had little to look at. That day was different. 

Later in her career, Timmons often told the story of hearing a loud thud followed by the screams of her students sitting nearest the window. Robert C. Fuller's body lay just outside.

Aftermath:

There were no known witnesses to the events in the tower leading up to Fuller's plunge. An autopsy concluded simply that the 62 year-old college treasurer had died as a result of trauma from the fall. 

Eva Fuller died two years later. Both she and her husband are buried in Tri-Cities Memorial Gardens, their graves marked by only modest bronze plaques. Today, the Bibb Graves tower is home to almost maintenance-free electronic chimes which can be programmed to play seasonal music. One has to wonder if Bob Fuller finds the sound lacking? 

Who Killed Andrea Susan Forbes?

 

Andrea Susan Forbes was born in Tennessee on October 9, 1983. Her official date of death is listed as January 21, 2017, the day her body was discovered, but it had been days since her neighbors had seen her - neighbors who didn't even know her name.

While living in the Johnson City area of Tennessee, Andrea gave birth to two daughters. The older child was given a home by the girl's biological father, while the second child was adopted. Not long after this second failed romance, Andrea met Matthew Troy Lindsey, whom friends said moved to Alabama to make a fresh start around the middle of 2013. 

Early in 2015, Andrea followed Matthew to Florence. Andrea had been abandoned by her parents, and family described her as being too trusting. While she was a certified welder, Andrea ostensibly never worked after arriving in the Shoals, and things did not always go smoothly with the couple.

By late 2015, Andrea and Matthew were residing at the Sherrod Apartments on the corner of Simpson Street and Florida Avenue. The complex was mid-sized, with the couple living on one end in #25. Other residents easily knew when the duo argued.

Matthew found himself in the Lauderdale County Detention Center in January 2017, charged with domestic abuse. His incarceration may have been the luckiest thing to have happened to him, since it cleared him of being directly involved in Andrea's death.

When police were called on January 21st to the ground floor apartment for a welfare check, officers looked through a window and saw what appeared to be a female body. Initially termed a death investigation, inquiries into Andrea's death quickly morphed into a homicide case when the initial autopsy results were released on January 25th.

Ten months soon passed without any progress being reported in the homicide investigation. Then Matthew Lindsay contacted the Shoalanda Speaks Blog stating that, at the time of her death, Andrea was pregnant with his child and he was offering a $6K reward for information leading to her killer.

Was any of that true? No. After the birth of her second child, Andrea had a tubal ligation and was unable to conceive. As for the 6K, Lindsey probably had less than $60.00 to his name. To fund the reward, he established a GoFundMe account which garnered only $25.00. He has since been in and out of jail numerous times; as of this publication, his last arrest was November 4th of this year when he was charged with a work release violation.

Florence CID has stated many details of Andrea's death have been held back in an effort to secure an arrest and conviction of her murderer. If you have any information concerning Andrea Susan Forbes' death, call 256-760-6500.